Horse Thief Lake Trail

MODERATE 36 reviews

Horse Thief Lake Trail is a 3.5 mile lightly trafficked out and back trail located near Keystone, South Dakota that features a lake and is rated as moderate. The trail offers a number of activity options and is best used from April until October. Dogs are also able to use this trail but must be kept on leash.

DISTANCE
3.5 miles
ELEVATION GAIN
764 feet
ROUTE TYPE
Out & Back

dogs on leash

camping

fishing

hiking

rock climbing

trail running

horseback riding

forest

lake

river

views

waterfall

wild flowers

wildlife

blowdown

old growth

hiking
1 day ago

hiking
4 days ago

Great hike. Moderate grade creeks and some great views when you get to the top. Only do the loop part if you are an experienced hiker and can bushwhack through the wilderness

hiking
14 days ago

A relatively easy hike until this loop at the southmost point. There is NO trail there. We persevered trying to make our way using GPS & finally did, but it was nothing less than treacherous and in my opinion DANGEROUS. This loop on this trip should NEVER have been left on the AllTrails site. We are very experienced hikers and never have encountered anything like this. Our worst hike ever (and we hike 72 miles/month)

hiking
19 days ago

hiking
29 days ago

hiking
1 month ago

hiking
1 month ago

More of a walk than a hike. Slight incline but mostly flat. Not much to see other than trees.

1 month ago

the end loop isnt marked, but other than that it was a variety of sights and types of trail, bolders, sands, gravel and rivers.

hiking
1 month ago

After reading the reviews, we headed straight out expecting no loop at the end. Sure enough, no readily visible loop. Tried following the GPS path for a bit also but turned back and just made it an out and back. Too many branches covering the path you were imagining more than seeing.

But for the path you could rely on it was great and covered overhead for most of the first half with paths that crisscrossed a small stream. Nice, cool and relaxing. The second half you got up high enough to see the rocks around you but not any long distance views. Most of the rocks you were seeing were actually those from the first half of the trip. Good spots to stop and rest around the rocks in the first half of the trip. There were plenty of Aspen and Birch trees along the route which would probably make it a good hike in the Fall as well.

Overall, a great hike for a cool June Day.

1 month ago

2 months ago

2 months ago

Nice easy trail. No loop though. We tried to find it but realized that it was purposefully covered with brush. Needs updating in this app.

2 months ago

Cool out and back trail with several views. It can get a little confusing so use the map on AllTrails. I attempted the loop at the end going counterclockwise. It is overgrown but easy until I got pass the half way point on the loop. It got harder then harder and even harder with deadwood and underbrush where I had to bail and cut back across. I do not recommend doing the loop.

2 months ago

loved the view and the hike was overall super easy

3 months ago

3 months ago

The loop at the end of the trail has been reclaimed by the forest.
We really enjoyed the trail.

4 months ago

hiking
5 months ago

8 months ago

Very nice trail, but I would consider this a walk through the woods instead of a hike. Trail #14 (horsethief) merges with centennial trail #89 shortly into the trail trek, so there is a variety of directions for a person to explore. All in all this trail is still a beautiful place to explore with streams, rock formations and birch trees around every corner!

10 months ago